WAGERBABE DOCS
Documentation
DocsEpics Validation Report

Epics Validation Report - WagerBabe Generated: January 13, 2025

Current Project Status: 80% Complete (10k-15k concurrent users achieved) Purpose: Validate epic breakdown accuracy against actual implementation state --- ## Executive Summary The epics.md file contains 18 epics with 92 total stories organized across 4 scaling phases. The epics were created when the project was at 0-5% completion. Since then, significant implementation has occurred (80% complete), requiring validation and potential reorganization. ### Key Findings GOOD: Epic structure logically organizes 162 requirements into implementable stories GOOD: Phase 1 epics (1-13) correctly prioritize infrastructure and core features GOOD: Epic 2 (Database Crisis) and Epic 3 (Caching) accurately identified Week 1-2 priorities OUTDATED: No completion status tracking - unclear which stories are done MISSING: Epic 2 Story 2.2 (PgBouncer) is documented but architecture.md shows asyncpg used instead ARCHITECTURAL DRIFT: Epics assume certain tech choices that differ from actual implementation --- ## Epic Completion Analysis ### Phase 1 Epics (Target: 1,000-10,000 Users) #### Epic 1: Foundation & Development Infrastructure Status: ~90% COMPLETE Stories Analysis:

  • 1.1: Repository setup (Next.js 15, FastAPI, dependencies)
  • 1.2: ESLint, Prettier, TypeScript strict mode
  • 1.3: GitHub Actions CI/CD (Railway deployment)
  • 1.4: Environment variables & secrets management
  • 1.5: Database migrations (Alembic confirmed in requirements.txt)
  • ⏳ 1.6: Testing infrastructure (pytest exists, coverage TBD) Evidence:
  • package.json shows Next.js 15.4.5, React 19.1.0, TypeScript 5.x - requirements.txt shows FastAPI 0.104.1, Alembic 1.13.1, pytest 7.4.3 - Railway deployment confirmed in architecture.md Remaining: Load testing setup, test coverage validation --- #### Epic 2: Database Crisis Management & Performance Optimization Status: 60% COMPLETE Stories Analysis:
  • 2.1: Emergency Odds Archival (97.4% -> <70%) - NOT STARTED - URGENT WEEK 3
  • 2.2: PgBouncer Setup - REPLACED with asyncpg connection pooling (10-50 connections)
  • 2.3: Sidebar Materialized View - NEEDS VALIDATION (materialized views mentioned in architecture.md as Week 3-4 priority)
  • 2.4: Database Query Optimization - LIKELY COMPLETE (asyncpg + caching = fast queries)
  • ⏳ 2.5: Database Backup Strategy - ASSUMED COMPLETE (Supabase managed backups)
  • ⏳ 2.6: Load Testing - PENDING Week 4 Evidence:
  • architecture.md Section 3.2: "asyncpg: 10-50 connections" (not PgBouncer) - architecture.md Section 4.4: "Database at 97.4% capacity - archival urgently needed" - architecture.md Week 3: "Materialized views for sidebar (<100ms target)" ⏳ Critical Gap: Story 2.1 (archival) is the primary blocker and not yet implemented. Technical Drift:
  • Epic assumes: PgBouncer for connection pooling
  • Actually used: asyncpg with native connection pooling (achieves same goal, different implementation)
  • Impact: Functional equivalent - no story update needed, just document variance --- #### Epic 3: Tiered Caching & API Optimization Status: 95% COMPLETE Stories Analysis:
  • 3.1: Redis Setup - COMPLETE (Redis 5.0.1 with 50 connection pool)
  • 3.2: Game Status Classifier - COMPLETE (HOT/WARM/COLD caching based on status)
  • 3.3: Tiered Caching Implementation - COMPLETE (95%+ cache hit ratio achieved)
  • 3.4: Request Batching & Deduplication - COMPLETE (cache offloads 98% of API calls)
  • 3.5: Cache Monitoring - COMPLETE (/health endpoint tracks cache metrics) Evidence:
  • architecture.md Section 3.3: "Redis 5.0.1 with hiredis, 50 connection pool" - architecture.md: "HOT (5min), WARM (1hr), COLD (24hr) caching strategies" - architecture.md: "95%+ cache hit ratio achieved" - architecture.md: "98% reduction in Odds API calls" Status: This epic is effectively complete and delivered the 20x performance improvement. --- #### Epic 4: User Authentication & Authorization Status: ~85% COMPLETE Stories: JWT auth, login, signup, logout, role-based access, password reset Evidence:
  • architecture.md: "JWT + Better Auth, Redis session caching, sub-10ms validation" - requirements.txt: PyJWT 2.8.0, python-jose 3.3.0, passlib 1.7.4 - client/.env.local: BETTER_AUTH_SECRET, JWT_SECRET_KEY configured Remaining: Password reset flow validation (may be deferred) --- #### Epic 5: Sports Catalog & High-Performance Sidebar Status: 75% COMPLETE Stories: Sports browsing, filtering, virtual scrolling, American sports prioritization Evidence:
  • architecture.md: "Virtual scrolling sidebar with TanStack Virtual" - Component layer shows sports sidebar components exist - package.json: @tanstack/react-virtual v3.13.12 Remaining: Materialized views for <100ms sidebar (Week 3-4 priority per architecture.md) --- #### Epic 6: Real-Time Odds Engine Status: ~90% COMPLETE Stories: WebSocket updates, multi-sportsbook comparison, tiered latency Evidence:
  • architecture.md: "WebSocket real-time odds updates (30s latency for live games)" - requirements.txt: websockets 12.0, aiohttp 3.8+ - architecture.md Section 3.5: "WebSocket architecture documented" Remaining: Load testing WebSocket capacity (Phase 1 Week 4) --- #### Epic 7: Betting Slip & Wager Processing Status: ~90% COMPLETE Stories: Add/remove bets, parlay calculation, zero data loss, slip persistence Evidence:
  • architecture.md: "Betting features (odds display, betting slip, parlay calculation, submission)" - Component layer: betting/ domain components exist Remaining: Comprehensive testing of parlay edge cases --- #### Epic 8: Agent Customer Management Hub Status: ~95% COMPLETE Stories: Customer CRUD, search/filter, view details, activate/deactivate Evidence:
  • architecture.md: "Agent Hub (customer management, cashier, settlements, reporting)" - Component layer: agent/ domain components extensive (customer-card, customer-table, etc.) Status: Effectively complete --- #### Epic 9: Agent Financial Operations Status: ~95% COMPLETE Stories: Cashier, credit/debit accounts, Tuesday settlements, compliance tracking Evidence:
  • architecture.md: "Agent Hub (customer management, cashier, Tuesday settlements, reporting)" - Component layer: cashier-module, balance-management-modal components exist - UX design: Tuesday settlement workflow documented Status: Effectively complete --- #### Epic 10: Agent Analytics & Reporting Status: ~90% COMPLETE Stories: Dashboard metrics, performance reports, export functionality Evidence:
  • Component layer: dashboard-stats, weekly-stats-panel, agent-stats-panel exist - Component layer: report-export-button confirmed Status: Effectively complete --- #### Epic 11: User Profile & Preferences Status: ~85% COMPLETE Stories: View/update profile, manage preferences Evidence:
  • Component layer: profile/ domain components exist --- #### Epic 12: Mobile-First Performance & Browser Support Status: 70% COMPLETE Stories: <3s mobile load, <1s navigation, PWA capabilities, cross-browser support Evidence:
  • architecture.md: "<3s initial mobile load, <1s page navigation" - package.json: next-pwa v5.6.0 (PWA configured) - globals.css: Mobile-first design with responsive breakpoints Remaining:
  • Lighthouse Mobile Score validation (target >90)
  • PWA service worker implementation (Phase 2) --- #### Epic 13: Observability, Monitoring & Deployment Status: ~80% COMPLETE Stories: Logging, dashboards, alerting, zero-downtime deploys, rollback Evidence:
  • architecture.md: "Sentry integration for error tracking" - architecture.md: "/health endpoint exposes metrics" - Railway deployment supports zero-downtime Remaining:
  • Custom dashboards (Datadog/New Relic - deferred to Phase 2)
  • Automated alerting setup --- ### Phase 2 Epics (Target: 10,000-25,000 Users) #### Epic 14: WebSocket & Background Job Scaling Status: PLANNED (Phase 2) Stories: Redis pub/sub, Celery workers, priority queues Current State: 4,000-6,000 WebSocket capacity documented but Phase 2 scaling not yet needed --- #### Epic 15: Advanced Observability & Progressive Deployment Status: PLANNED (Phase 2) Stories: Distributed tracing, feature flags, canary releases --- ### Phase 3-4 Epics (Target: 25,000-50,000 Users) #### Epic 16-18: Advanced Scaling Status: FUTURE PHASES Epics: CDN/read replicas (Phase 3), PWA offline (Phase 3), multi-region/sharding (Phase 4) --- ## Story Completion Summary ### Estimated Completion by Epic (18 Epics Total) | Epic | Name | Stories | Est. Complete | Status | |------|------|---------|---------------|--------| | Epic 1 | Foundation & Infra | 6 | 5.5/6 (90%) | Nearly done | | Epic 2 | Database Crisis | 6 | 3.5/6 (60%) | Archival URGENT | | Epic 3 | Tiered Caching | 5 | 4.75/5 (95%) | Complete | | Epic 4 | Authentication | ~4 | ~3.5/4 (85%) | Core done | | Epic 5 | Sports Sidebar | ~4 | ~3/4 (75%) | Needs optimization | | Epic 6 | Real-Time Odds | ~4 | ~3.5/4 (90%) | Core done | | Epic 7 | Betting Slip | ~5 | ~4.5/5 (90%) | Core done | | Epic 8 | Agent Customers | ~5 | ~4.75/5 (95%) | Complete | | Epic 9 | Agent Finance | ~6 | ~5.75/6 (95%) | Complete | | Epic 10 | Agent Reports | ~4 | ~3.5/4 (90%) | Core done | | Epic 11 | User Profile | ~3 | ~2.5/3 (85%) | Core done | | Epic 12 | Mobile Performance | ~4 | ~2.75/4 (70%) | Needs validation | | Epic 13 | Observability | ~5 | ~4/5 (80%) | Core done | | Phase 1 Subtotal | 13 epics | ~61 stories | ~51/61 (84%) | ** Close to complete** | | Epic 14-15 | Phase 2 | ~10 | 0/10 (0%) | Planned | | Epic 16-18 | Phase 3-4 | ~21 | 0/21 (0%) | Future | | TOTAL | 18 epics | ~92 stories | ~51/92 (55%) | ** Phase 1 focus** | Note: Story counts are approximate - full epic document has detailed breakdowns. --- ## Critical Gaps Identified ### URGENT - Week 3 1. Epic 2, Story 2.1: Database Archival (NOT STARTED)
  • Issue: Database at 97.4% capacity
  • Epic Says: Archive odds older than 7 days to CSV -> S3/Supabase Storage
  • Reality: Not implemented, blocking all user onboarding
  • Action: Implement Week 3 per architecture.md recommendations 2. Epic 2, Story 2.3: Sidebar Materialized Views (PARTIAL)
  • Issue: Sidebar loads fast via caching but materialized views not confirmed
  • Epic Says: <100ms cached, <300ms uncached with materialized view
  • Reality: Architecture.md lists this as Week 3-4 priority
  • Action: Create materialized views, validate performance ### HIGH PRIORITY - Week 4 3. Epic 2, Story 2.6: Load Testing (PENDING)
  • Issue: 10k-15k capacity achieved but not validated under sustained load
  • Epic Says: Load test at 1.5x peak capacity
  • Reality: Architecture.md marks this as Week 4 priority
  • Action: Automated load testing with Locust/k6 4. Epic 12: Mobile Performance Validation (PARTIAL)
  • Issue: Mobile-first design exists but Lighthouse scores not validated
  • Epic Says: Lighthouse Mobile Score >90
  • Reality: Package.json has scripts but scores not measured
  • Action: Run Lighthouse CI, optimize bundle size ### ℹ MEDIUM PRIORITY - Phase 2 5. Epic 13: Advanced Monitoring (PARTIAL)
  • Issue: Basic monitoring exists (Sentry, /health) but no dashboards
  • Epic Says: Real-time dashboards, automated alerting
  • Reality: Deferred to Phase 2 per architecture.md
  • Action: Integrate Datadog/New Relic when approaching 25k users --- ## Technical Drift Analysis ### Architectural Decisions That Differ from Epics 1. PgBouncer vs asyncpg
  • Epic 2 Story 2.2: Deploy PgBouncer for connection pooling
  • Actual Implementation: asyncpg native connection pooling (10-50 connections)
  • Impact: Functional equivalent - same goal achieved differently
  • Recommendation: Document variance in epic notes, no story change needed 2. Redis Deployment
  • Epic 3 Story 3.1: Redis Cloud free tier (30 MB)
  • Actual Implementation: Redis on Railway (managed instance)
  • Impact: Better solution - private network, easier scaling
  • Recommendation: Update epic with "Railway Redis" as preferred deployment 3. Better Auth Addition
  • Epic 4: JWT auth with Supabase Auth
  • Actual Implementation: JWT + Better Auth library
  • Impact: Enhancement - modern auth library added
  • Recommendation: Add Better Auth to Epic 4 stories 4. Component Layer System
  • Epics: Don't mention 5-layer component architecture
  • Actual Implementation: Sophisticated layer system (ui -> universal -> domain -> composite)
  • Impact: Better organization than assumed
  • Recommendation: Add Epic 1 story documenting component architecture standards --- ## Recommendations ### 1. Add Completion Status Tracking Recommendation: Add status badges to each epic/story header Example Format:
### Epic 2: Database Crisis Management **Status:** 60% COMPLETE (3.5/6 stories done) #### Story 2.1: Emergency Odds Archival
**Status:** NOT STARTED - URGENT WEEK 3
**Assigned:** TBD
**Target:** Week 3 #### Story 2.2: PgBouncer Setup
**Status:** COMPLETE (asyncpg used instead)
**Implementation:** asyncpg connection pooling (10-50 connections)
**Completed:** Week 2
``` ### 2. Create "Current Sprint" View **Recommendation:** Add section at top of epics.md showing Week 3-4 priorities **Example:**
```markdown
## Current Sprint: Phase 1 Week 3-4 ### Week 3 Priorities (Database Crisis Resolution)
- [ ] **Story 2.1:** Emergency Odds Archival (97.4% -> <70%) - URGENT
- [ ] **Story 2.3:** Sidebar Materialized Views (<100ms)
- [ ] **Story 2.4:** Query Optimization (N+1 elimination) ### Week 4 Priorities (Validation & Performance)
- [ ] **Story 2.6:** Load Testing (10k-15k concurrent users)
- [ ] **Story 12.x:** Lighthouse Mobile Score Validation
- [ ] **Story 5.x:** Virtual Scrolling Performance Tuning ### Blockers
- Database at 97.4% capacity (Story 2.1 blocks all user onboarding)
``` ### 3. Document Technical Decisions **Recommendation:** Add "Technical Decisions" section to epics documenting variances **Example:**
```markdown
## Technical Decisions Log ### Decision 1: asyncpg vs PgBouncer (Week 2)
- **Epic Assumption:** Deploy PgBouncer for connection pooling
- **Actual Choice:** Use asyncpg native pooling (10-50 connections)
- **Rationale:** Simpler deployment, achieves same capacity (10k-15k users)
- **Impact:** Epic 2 Story 2.2 considered complete with different implementation ### Decision 2: Better Auth Library (Week 2)
- **Epic Assumption:** JWT with Supabase Auth only
- **Actual Choice:** Added Better Auth library for modern auth patterns
- **Rationale:** Better DX, session management, Telegram OAuth integration
- **Impact:** Epic 4 enhanced beyond original scope
``` ### 4. Update Epic Metadata **Recommendation:** Add completion metadata to epic headers **Example:**
```markdown
## Epic 3: Tiered Caching & API Optimization
**Epic Goal:** Reduce API usage from 100% -> <50% via intelligent caching
**Phase:** Phase 1 (Week 2)
**Status:** COMPLETE (Week 2)
**Achievement:** 95%+ cache hit ratio, 98% API cost reduction, 20x performance improvement
**Stories Complete:** 5/5 (100%)
**Dependencies:** Epic 1 (foundation), Epic 2 (database pooling)
``` ### 5. Reorganize by Current Reality **Recommendation:** Optionally reorganize epics into 3 sections **Structure:**
```markdown
## Completed Epics (Phase 1 Weeks 1-2)
- Epic 1: Foundation (90% complete)
- Epic 3: Tiered Caching (95% complete)
- Epic 4-11: Core Features (80-95% complete each) ## ⏳ In Progress (Phase 1 Weeks 3-4)
- Epic 2: Database Crisis (60% complete - archival blocking)
- Epic 5: Sports Sidebar (75% complete - optimization pending)
- Epic 12: Mobile Performance (70% complete - validation pending)
- Epic 13: Observability (80% complete - dashboards pending) ## Planned (Phase 2-4)
- Epic 14-15: Phase 2 Scaling
- Epic 16-18: Phase 3-4 Enterprise
``` --- ## Validation Summary ### Epic Accuracy: 80% **What's Correct (80%):**
- Epic structure logically organizes 162 requirements
- Phase 1 epics correctly prioritize infrastructure and core features
- Epic 2 (Database Crisis) and Epic 3 (Caching) accurately identified critical path
- Story acceptance criteria are clear and testable
- Technical notes provide implementation guidance **What Needs Update (20%):**
- No completion status tracking (unclear which stories are done)
- Technical drift not documented (PgBouncer -> asyncpg, Better Auth addition)
- No "current sprint" view showing Week 3-4 priorities
- Story counts not explicitly tracked (estimated ~92 stories total) ### Next Actions **For User:**
1. Review this validation report
2. Decide if epic status updates are priority (vs continuing implementation)
3. Confirm Week 3-4 priorities: Database archival -> Sidebar optimization -> Load testing **For Development:**
1. **Week 3 PRIORITY:** Story 2.1 - Emergency Odds Archival (97.4% -> <70%)
2. **Week 3:** Story 2.3 - Sidebar Materialized Views
3. **Week 4:** Story 2.6 - Load Testing validation --- **Report Status:** Complete
**Epics Overall Assessment:** GOOD structure, needs status tracking and minor updates
**Critical Finding:** Epic 2 Story 2.1 (archival) is the primary blocker - already identified in PRD and architecture.md **Estimated Total Stories:** ~92 (61 Phase 1, 31 Phase 2-4)
**Estimated Stories Complete:** ~51/92 (55% overall, 84% of Phase 1)
**Aligns with Project 80% Complete Status:** Yes (Phase 1 focus = 84% complete)